He laughed it off, said he'd try to reply faster when he saw my messages.

He never pinned me.

When I brought it up again, he sighed and said he had too many work contacts for pinning to matter.

I let him talk me out of it. But the gray feeling stayed.

It wasn't until much, much later that I understood what that feeling was.

The quiet ache of not mattering enough.

Their chat history looked harmless.

Glenda shared a sunrise; Chester sent back a rainbow after the rain.

Nothing that would look wrong if anyone else read it—every message carefully inside the line marked "friends."

But that kind of idle, pointless back-and-forth had disappeared from my life with Chester a long time ago.

Our messages had been reduced to a handful of cold templates.

Working late? Have you eaten? Did the contract get signed?

I was about to close the chat when I accidentally tapped into his saved messages.

There was a pinned voice note from Glenda.

I pressed play. A bright, clear female voice filled the room.

"Chester, if you hadn't been so sharp-tongued back then, maybe we wouldn't have missed our chance."

The timestamp was three years ago.

The same day Chester lost his voice.